This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.
| 4 minute read

Federal Court Largely Denies Motion to Dismiss in Cookie Banner Malfunction Privacy Class Action

On August 29, 2025, Judge William H. Orrick of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, largely denied defendant’s motion to dismiss a putative class action alleging that a major consumer healthcare company continued to deploy third-party tracking cookies on users’ devices even after those users explicitly clicked “Reject All” on the company’s cookie consent banner. The court allowed six of seven claims to proceed, dismissing only the trespass to chattels claim (with leave to amend). This decision reinforces the growing trend in the Northern District of California of permitting privacy claims to advance where plaintiffs allege that a website operator affirmatively disregarded users’ cookie opt-out choices.

Background

Plaintiff Jonathan Gabrielli alleged that Haleon US Inc., one of the world’s largest consumer healthcare businesses, operates websites for well-known brands including Tums, Advil, Centrum, Theraflu, Flonase, Sensodyne, and Emergen-C. When California consumers visit these websites, they are presented with a pop-up cookie consent banner offering the option to “Reject All” or “Accept Cookies.” Gabrielli visited several of these websites between August 2023 and June 2024 and selected “Reject All” each time, believing that doing so would prevent the placement or use of all non-essential cookies and third-party tracking technologies.

Despite Gabrielli’s express rejection, Haleon allegedly continued to cause the placement and transmission of cookies on his device, including performance, targeting, and social media cookies from third parties. These cookies allegedly enabled third parties to track and collect in real time a broad range of personal data, including browsing history, visit history, website interactions, user input data (such as search queries, name, age, gender, email address, location, and payment information), demographic information, interests and preferences, shopping behaviors, device information, and geolocation data.

Gabrielli asserted seven causes of action on behalf of himself and a proposed class of California residents: (1) invasion of privacy; (2) intrusion upon seclusion; (3) wiretapping in violation of the California Invasion of Privacy Act (“CIPA”), Cal. Penal Code § 631; (4) use of a pen register in violation of CIPA, Cal. Penal Code § 638.51; (5) common law fraud; (6) unjust enrichment; and (7) trespass to chattels.

Key Holdings

Article III Standing. The court held that Gabrielli sufficiently alleged a concrete injury to his right to privacy sufficient for Article III standing. Relying on the Ninth Circuit’s decision in In re Facebook, Inc. Internet Tracking Litigation, 956 F.3d 589 (9th Cir. 2020), which held that violations of the right to privacy have long been actionable at common law and that statutes like CIPA codify a substantive right to privacy, the court concluded that Gabrielli’s allegations that Haleon deprived him of control over personal information regarding his digital activity and profile were sufficient. The court distinguished cases involving mere disclosure of IP addresses, where plaintiffs had no reasonable expectation of privacy, from this case involving far broader categories of personal data collected after an express opt-out.

The court also addressed the Ninth Circuit’s recent decision in Popa v. Microsoft Corp., 153 F.4th 784 (9th Cir. 2025), finding it factually distinguishable because the plaintiff in Popa challenged session-replay technology on a pet supply website, never expressly rejected tracking, and the information collected was less sensitive than healthcare-related browsing data at issue here.

Invasion of Privacy and Intrusion Upon Seclusion. The court denied the motion to dismiss these claims, holding that it could not conclude as a matter of law at the pleading stage that the alleged transmission of Gabrielli’s browsing data, visit history, website interactions, geolocation information, user input data, and other data was not a highly offensive invasion of his reasonable privacy expectation. The court emphasized that courts must be “reluctant to reach a conclusion at the pleading stage about how offensive or serious the privacy intrusion is.”

CIPA Claims — Statute of Limitations. The court applied the discovery rule to toll CIPA’s one-year statute of limitations, finding that the case was based on Haleon’s use of “highly technical proprietary software,” that Gabrielli lacked the technical knowledge to test whether the websites honored his cookie rejection, and that the earliest he could have known about the injury was shortly before filing. The court rejected Haleon’s argument that Gabrielli had “actual notice” because he had reviewed the cookie banner and privacy notice, reasoning that Gabrielli expressly opted to reject all cookies — an option Haleon offered — which contradicted any claim that he was on notice of the alleged wrongdoing.

CIPA Claims — Wiretapping (§ 631) and Pen Registers (§ 638.51). The court found that Gabrielli sufficiently alleged the “contents” of communications by identifying user input data including search queries, names, email addresses, location, and payment information — not merely IP addresses or button clicks. The court also held that third-party trackers could constitute “pen registers” under CIPA, rejecting Haleon’s argument that the statute applies only to telephone technology, and following the weight of authority interpreting the statute’s “expansive language” to apply to internet tracking technologies. Notably, the court rejected Haleon’s argument that wiretapping and pen register claims could not coexist, agreeing with the reasoning in In re Meta Pixel Tax Filing Cases that CIPA’s purpose to protect privacy would be undermined by such an interpretation.

Fraud. The court denied the motion to dismiss the fraud claim, finding that Gabrielli’s allegations — that Haleon represented users could “Reject All” cookies when in fact it continued to deploy them — were pleaded with sufficient particularity under Rule 9(b). The court also found that damages based on the diminution in value of private and personally identifiable information were sufficient at the pleading stage.

Trespass to Chattels (Dismissed with Leave to Amend). The only claim dismissed was trespass to chattels. The court found that Gabrielli failed to plausibly allege that the non-consensual storage of cookies impaired the condition, quality, or value of his computer, noting that cookies are “miniscule in size” and generally incapable of noticeably affecting computer performance. The claim was dismissed with leave to amend.

Unjust Enrichment. The court allowed this claim to proceed, noting that California law recognizes a right to disgorgement of profits resulting from unjust enrichment even where the plaintiff has not suffered a corresponding loss.

Punitive Damages. The court permitted Gabrielli’s request for punitive damages to proceed, finding that the plausibility of his fraud claim supported a basis for alleging that Haleon acted with “oppression, fraud, or malice.”

Gabrielli v. Haleon US Inc., No. 25-cv-02555-WHO (N.D. Cal. Aug. 29, 2025).

Tags

art iii injury-in-fact, cipa 63851, cipa section 631
chevron-up