This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.
| 1 minute read

Federal Court Denies Motion to Dismiss in Washington Email Marketing Case, Confirms CEMA Is Not Preempted by Federal Law

On February 27, 2026, the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Washington denied Ulta Salon, Cosmetics & Fragrance, Inc.’s motion to dismiss a putative class action alleging that the retailer’s promotional emails violated Washington’s Commercial Electronic Mail Act (“CEMA”) and Consumer Protection Act (“CPA”). The court rejected arguments that CEMA is preempted by the federal CAN-SPAM Act and rejected challenges to CEMA’s constitutionality under the dormant Commerce Clause.

Background

Plaintiffs alleged that Ulta sent promotional emails with subject lines containing false or misleading statements about the duration and availability of promotional offers. According to the complaint, the emails created a false sense of urgency by implying that promotions were time-limited, when in fact the same or similar offers were extended or reinstated after the purported deadline. The State of Washington intervened in the case.

Key Holdings

Pleading Standards. The court found that the amended complaint adequately alleged the elements of a CEMA claim, including that Ulta (1) initiated commercial emails (2) with false or misleading subject lines (3) to addresses the sender knew or had reason to know were held by Washington residents. The court credited allegations that Ulta had multiple ways of knowing or having reason to know recipients were Washington residents, including through purchase history, account information, IP address tracking, and data broker services.

No CAN-SPAM Preemption. The court rejected Ulta’s argument that CEMA is expressly preempted by the federal CAN-SPAM Act. The CAN-SPAM Act specifically allows states to prohibit “falsity or deception” in commercial emails, and CEMA’s subject-line provision falls squarely within this exception. The court also rejected the argument that plaintiffs must plead the elements of common law fraud, noting that CEMA does not “sound in fraud” and Congress intentionally used the broader language of “falsity or deception” rather than “fraud” in crafting the exception.

No Dormant Commerce Clause Violation. The court rejected Ulta’s constitutional challenge on all three dormant Commerce Clause grounds. First, CEMA does not discriminate against out-of-state businesses because it applies evenhandedly to in-state and out-of-state senders. Second, CEMA does not improperly regulate extraterritorial conduct because it regulates activities targeting Washington residents, even if those residents are temporarily located elsewhere. Third, increased compliance costs alone do not constitute a substantial burden on interstate commerce sufficient to trigger Pike balancing.

State of Washington v. Ulta Salon, Cosmetics & Fragrance, Inc., No. 2:25-cv-00284-RLP (E.D. Wash. Feb. 27, 2026).

Tags

cema
chevron-up