On February 26, 2026, the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan denied a motion to dismiss in Specialty Medical Equipment, Inc. v. Dobronski, allowing fraud and civil RICO claims to proceed against an individual alleged to have used false identities to manufacture Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) claims against businesses. The decision is significant for companies facing TCPA litigation and provides a potential roadmap for pursuing counterclaims against abusive litigation tactics.
Background
Specialty Medical Equipment, Inc. is a durable medical equipment (DME) provider that serves patients who often rely on Medicare or other insurance. The company alleged that Mark Dobronski, described as a “serial plaintiff” who frequently pursues TCPA claims against businesses, adopted a false identity to solicit a callback from Specialty Medical. According to the complaint, Dobronski called Specialty Medical using an alias, provided a false Medicare identification number, fabricated a narrative about needing medical supplies, and provided a callback number registered on the National Do Not Call Registry. When Specialty Medical called the number to follow up, Dobronski allegedly revealed his true identity and asserted that the company had violated the TCPA.
Specialty Medical brought claims for state law fraud and civil RICO violations, seeking damages for wasted time, resources, and reputational harm.
Fraud Claim
Dobronski argued that the fraud claim should be dismissed because Specialty Medical failed to establish justifiable reliance, particularly given the company’s regulatory obligations to independently verify patient eligibility under Medicare requirements. The court rejected this argument, finding that Specialty Medical adequately alleged reliance by claiming it “incurred expense in pursuing the set-up of a DME supply relationship” and suffered “humiliation and embarrassment” from communications with third parties based on Dobronski’s false representations. The court emphasized that a later verification process would not prevent or undo the injury caused by the initial fraudulent contact.
RICO Claim
The court found Specialty Medical sufficiently pleaded all elements of a civil RICO claim:
- Enterprise: The court held that Specialty Medical adequately alleged an association-in-fact enterprise between Dobronski and his LLC, Safe Train, citing the Supreme Court’s liberal standard under Boyle v. United States. The allegations that Dobronski used Safe Train’s communications equipment and acted in concert with his wife were sufficient to establish the required relationships.
- Predicate Acts: The court found the complaint satisfied Rule 9(b)’s heightened pleading requirements for wire fraud, noting that Specialty Medical identified the specific dates, locations, phone numbers, and content of Dobronski’s alleged misrepresentations.
- Pattern: The court found the pattern requirement satisfied by allegations that Dobronski had admitted in two prior TCPA cases to using false identities to gather information for potential claims.
Noerr-Pennington Doctrine
Dobronski argued that his conduct was protected petitioning activity under the First Amendment’s Noerr-Pennington doctrine. The court disagreed, finding that allegations of intentional fraudulent misrepresentation—using a false name, providing false medical information, and engaging in a scheme to defraud—were sufficient to overcome any constitutional protection.
SPECIALTY MEDICAL EQUIPMENT, INC. v. MARK DOBRONSKI, No. 25-CV-10664, 2026 WL 540262 (E.D. Mich. Feb. 26, 2026).
