On February 19, 2026, Judge Wesley L. Hsu, in the Central District of California, issued a ruling in Sandy Asad v. Dicks Sporting Goods, Inc. confirming a final arbitration award in favor of Dicks Sporting Goods, Inc.. This decision offers important guidance for companies facing website privacy litigation under the Federal Wiretap Act and the California Invasion of Privacy Act (“CIPA”).
Background
The plaintiff brought claims alleging that Dicks Sporting Goods violated the Federal Wiretap Act and CIPA by “intentionally acquiring the contents of [her] electronic communications” using software on the company’s website without her consent. These claims arose from the plaintiff’s visits to the defendant’s website and her purchases made through the site.
Because the defendant’s Terms of Use contained a binding arbitration agreement, the matter was compelled to arbitration, which was administered pursuant to JAMS Streamlined Rules. Following a multi-day merits hearing, the arbitrator issued a final award on December 8, 2025, determining that the defendant was the prevailing party.
The Arbitrator’s Findings
The arbitrator found that the plaintiff failed to establish a violation of either the Wiretap Act or CIPA for several reasons:
First, the communications at issue were not intercepted “in transit” within the meaning of either statute. Second, the plaintiff did not present sufficient evidence showing transmission of her personally identifiable information to relevant third parties. Third, the arbitrator concluded that the plaintiff gave constructive consent based on her use of the website and notice of the company’s privacy practices. Finally, the arbitrator found that the defendant’s expert testimony was more credible and persuasive than that of the plaintiff’s expert.
The Court’s Confirmation Order
Following the arbitration, the defendant moved to confirm the award in federal court. The plaintiff opposed the motion, arguing that the defendant lacked standing because “there is no live controversy for this Court to decide”.
The court rejected this argument, emphasizing that judicial review of arbitration awards under the Federal Arbitration Act is “extremely narrow and deferential”. Confirmation is required unless a party establishes one of the limited grounds for vacatur under Section 10 of the FAA—such as fraud, arbitrator partiality, misconduct, or the arbitrator exceeding their powers—or grounds for modification under Section 11. The plaintiff did not assert any of these recognized grounds. Accordingly, the court granted the motion and confirmed the final arbitration award.
Sandy Asad v. Dicks Sporting Goods, Inc., No. 2:22-CV-09366-WLH-MAA, 2026 WL 530757 (C.D. Cal. Feb. 19, 2026).
