This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.
| 1 minute read

California Court of Appeal Clarifies Tenant Standing Under ICRAA and UCL

On January 23, 2026, the California Court of Appeal addressed whether tenants can pursue claims under the Investigative Consumer Reporting Agencies Act (ICRAA) and the Unfair Competition Law (UCL) without showing actual damages.

Between November 9, 2020 to July 22, 2022, more than 100 plaintiffs filed individual complaints against Barrington alleging causes of action for violations of ICRAA. Each complaint alleged that Barrington failed to: (1) provide plaintiffs with a means of requesting a copy of their consumer reports, (2) disclose the identity of the consumer reporting agency that procured the report, (3) inform plaintiffs that investigative consumer reports would be prepared regarding their [*5]  character, general reputation, personal characteristics, and mode of living, and (4) furnish or offer to furnish plaintiffs with copies of the reports. Three plaintiffs also alleged a second cause of action under the UCL.

ICRAA Claims: Statutory Penalties Without Proof of Harm

The court held that tenants do not need to prove actual harm to have standing under ICRAA. The statute’s language allows for a statutory penalty of $10,000 for violations of informational rights, such as failing to disclose the identity of the consumer reporting agency, not informing applicants about the nature of investigative consumer reports, or not providing a means to request copies of such reports. The court emphasized that the $10,000 penalty is punitive and operates as an alternative to actual damages, serving as a deterrent and motivating compliance with ICRAA’s requirements. This means that even if tenants suffer no concrete injury, they may still recover statutory penalties for violations.

UCL Claims: Economic Injury Required

In contrast, the court affirmed that standing under the UCL requires plaintiffs to demonstrate both injury in fact and economic loss. The tenants in this case argued that paying an application fee without receiving a copy of their consumer report constituted a loss of money or property. However, the court found that the application fee was for processing and screening, not for providing a copy of the report. Since the tenants received the screening service and their rental applications were approved, they did not suffer any financial harm or loss of property. The court concluded that the failure to provide a copy of the report did not amount to an “injury in fact” under the UCL, and therefore, the tenants lacked standing to pursue these claims.

Yeh v. Barrington Pac., LLC, No. B337904, 2026 Cal. App. LEXIS 30 (Ct. App. Jan. 21, 2026).

Tags

ceb ch 2c privacy laws affecting debtors and debt collection, viid investig consumer reporting agencies act icraa §2c22, vii consumer credit reporting agencies act ccraa, investigative consumer reporting agencies act icraa
chevron-up