This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.
| 3 minute read

Court Dismisses Data Privacy Claims Against Apple Re Its Native Apps

On January 20, 2026, Judge Edward J. Davila, in the Northern District of California, granted Apple’s motion to dismiss a series of data privacy claims brought by users of Apple’s mobile devices. Plaintiffs alleged that Apple improperly collected user data through its proprietary apps, even when users had disabled certain data-sharing settings. The court’s order addresses claims under California and Pennsylvania law, as well as related contract and unjust enrichment theories, ultimately finding the plaintiffs’ allegations insufficient but allowing them an opportunity to amend their complaint.

Claims Under Scrutiny

Plaintiffs’ claims centered on Apple’s collection of user data from its first-party apps (such as the App Store and Apple Music), despite users disabling the “Share [Device] Analytics” setting. The court evaluated claims under:

  • California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA) Sections 632 and 638.51
  • Pennsylvania Wiretapping and Electronic Surveillance Act (WESCA)
  • California Constitution (right to privacy)
  • California Unfair Competition Law (UCL)
  • Implied contract and unjust enrichment

1. CIPA Pen Register Provision (Section 638.51)
The court found that plaintiffs failed to identify a “pen register” as defined by statute, as Apple’s apps and their processes are not separate from the source of the communication. The court also noted inconsistencies in the plaintiffs’ theories and allegations, leading to dismissal of this claim.

Plaintiffs did not indicate that they plead their pen register claim as an alternative to their Section 632 claim. In fact, in their pen register claim, Plaintiffs expressly “incorporate[d] by reference and re-allege[d] each and every allegation set forth in paragraphs 1 through 105” (FAC ¶ 182), including their allegation that Apple’s apps captured “confidential communications” (id. ¶¶ 11–20). These inconsistent allegations and causes of action are another ground for dismissal of Plaintiffs’ pen register claim. U.S. Med. Instruments, Inc. v. CFS N. Am., Inc., 2013 WL 6055387, at *9 (S.D. Cal. Nov. 13,
2013) (“The Ninth Circuit has held that where inconsistent allegations are not pled in the alternative, but are expressly incorporated into each cause of action, an allegation may constitute a judicial admission by the plaintiff which allows dismissal of the complaint.”) (citing Maloney v. Scottsdale Ins. Co., 256 F. App’x 29, 31 (9th Cir. 2007)).

2. CIPA Eavesdropping Provision (Section 632)
The court held that plaintiffs did not adequately allege that the data Apple collected was “confidential” or constituted a “communication” under the statute, with the exception of one plaintiff’s specific search terms. The court reaffirmed that users of internet-connected apps generally do not have a reasonable expectation of privacy in data that is inherently recorded as part of the service.

As internet-connected applications, Apple’s apps operate using the client-server model, in which client devices—here, Plaintiffs’ mobile devices—request services from Apple’s servers that then record the request and transmit the requested information back to the client devices. These device-to-server transmissions are “by their very nature recorded on the [device] of at least the recipient” and thus are not “confidential” communications under Section 632. See In re Google Inc. Gmail Litig., 2013 WL 5423918, at *23 (N.D. Cal. Sept. 26, 2013) (emails not “confidential” under Section 632). Plaintiffs do not dispute that Apple’s apps operate in this manner. They instead assert that their withdrawal of consent by turning off the “Share [Device] Analytics” setting created a reasonable expectation that none of their usage data2 would be sent to Apple. The Court disagrees. Consumers may hold a subjective expectation that no usage data would be sent to Apple, but that expectation is objectively unreasonable. As the Court stated in in its previous Order, “[n]o reasonable consumer would expect to engage in a transaction with Apple without some data being collected from Apple to process that transaction.” MTD Order at 29–30. The same continues to apply with equal force here. Plaintiffs allege Apple collects myriad data points that fall under the definition of “usage data,” but almost all of this data is of the kind one would expect Apple would need to collect in order to respond to Plaintiffs’ requests. See FAC ¶¶ 55–59.

3. WESCA (Pennsylvania Law)
The court dismissed the WESCA claim, finding that the plaintiffs did not allege Apple collected the “contents” of communications, nor did they identify a separate intercepting device as required by the statute.

4. California Constitutional Privacy
The court determined that plaintiffs failed to show a reasonable expectation of privacy in the data collected by Apple, particularly as the data was not shown to be highly sensitive or outside the scope of what users would expect Apple to collect in the course of providing its services.

5. Unfair Competition Law (UCL)
The court found that plaintiffs did not sufficiently allege economic injury, as their claims regarding the value of their data and any price premium paid for Apple devices were too speculative and conclusory.

6. Implied Contract and Unjust Enrichment
The court dismissed these claims, noting that plaintiffs did not allege the invalidity or unenforceability of their express contracts with Apple, which is required to plead alternative quasi-contract theories.

7. Game Center Allegations
Claims based on Apple’s Game Center were dismissed, as plaintiffs did not allege that they personally used Game Center or that it collected their data.

In Re : Apple Data Priv. Litig., N.D. Cal., No. 5:22-cv-07069 (Jan. 20, 2026).

Tags

cipa, cipa 632, cipa 63851, invasion of privacy
chevron-up