A recent decision from the District of Delaware addresses the reach of U.S. courts over foreign companies in class actions under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA). The case centers on allegations that an Australian wellness company sent repeated marketing text messages to a Delaware resident, even after her number was listed on the federal Do-Not-Call Registry. The plaintiff sought to represent a class of individuals who received multiple telemarketing messages from the company despite being on the registry.
Personal Jurisdiction: Expanding the Reach of U.S. Courts
Defendant moved to dismiss the case, arguing the court lacked personal jurisdiction and that the complaint failed to state a claim. The court’s analysis focused on Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 4(k)(2), which allows federal courts to exercise jurisdiction over foreign defendants in federal law cases when no single state court has jurisdiction.
Key points from the court’s jurisdictional analysis include:
- Purposeful Contacts: The company had established minimum contacts with the United States by partnering with U.S.-based marketing platforms and sending targeted text advertisements to American consumers, including messages referencing U.S. holidays and benefits relevant only to Americans.
- Rule 4(k)(2) Application: The court adopted a burden-shifting approach, requiring the plaintiff to make a prima facie case for jurisdiction, after which the defendant must show it could be sued in a state court or that jurisdiction would be unconstitutional. The defendant conceded it could not be sued in any state court, focusing its challenge on constitutional grounds.
- Constitutional Analysis Post-Fuld: The court considered the Supreme Court’s recent decision in Fuld v. Palestine Liberation Organization, which clarified that the Fifth Amendment’s due process standard for federal courts is more flexible than the Fourteenth Amendment’s standard for state courts. The court found that exercising jurisdiction over the foreign company was constitutional under both pre- and post-Fuld standards, given the company’s deliberate targeting of the U.S. market.
TCPA Claims: What Survives and What Does Not
After establishing jurisdiction, the court addressed the sufficiency of the plaintiff’s claims under the TCPA and its implementing regulations:
- Do-Not-Call Registry Violations: The court allowed the claim that the company violated the FCC’s ban on contacting numbers listed on the Do-Not-Call Registry to proceed. The plaintiff adequately alleged receipt of multiple marketing texts after registering her number, and the court found that consent is an affirmative defense not required to be rebutted at the pleading stage.
- Treble Damages: The court dismissed the standalone claim for treble damages, clarifying that enhanced damages for willful or knowing violations are not a separate cause of action but rather an element of damages under the TCPA.
- Quiet Hours Rule: The claim that the company violated the FCC’s “quiet hours” rule (prohibiting calls before 8 a.m. or after 9 p.m.) was dismissed. The court found that the plaintiff had given prior express consent to receive marketing texts, as evidenced by her subscription to the company’s messages, and thus the quiet hours provision did not apply.
King v. Bon Charge, No. 25-CV-00105-SB, 2025 WL 3764039 (D. Del. Dec. 30, 2025).
