Judge Christina A. Snyder, in the Central District of California, dismissed all claims in a lawsuit alleging privacy violations by a music merchandise website, finding that the plaintiff failed to demonstrate a concrete injury sufficient for Article III standing.
Plaintiff, a California resident and self-described privacy “tester,” alleged that the defendant’s website secretly deployed a Magnite tracking pixel, which purportedly collected and transmitted personal information to a third-party data broker. The complaint asserted violations of the federal Wiretap Act, California’s trap and trace law under the California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA), and the common law tort of intrusion upon seclusion. The plaintiff claimed that the tracking pixel harvested sensitive data—including IP addresses, device identifiers, and browsing behavior—without user consent, and that these practices were deceptive and highly offensive.
Legal Standards for Standing
To proceed in federal court, a plaintiff must show a concrete, particularized injury that is actual or imminent, causally linked to the defendant’s conduct, and redressable by judicial relief. The defendant argued that the plaintiff’s allegations were too generalized and failed to identify any specific harm resulting from her visit to the website. The court agreed, noting that the complaint only established that the plaintiff visited the website and that her IP address and similar metadata may have been collected—information routinely exchanged during internet browsing and not typically considered a privacy violation under federal law.
No Concrete Injury
The court found that plaintiff’s status as a privacy “tester” did not automatically defeat standing, but her allegations lacked the necessary specificity to establish a concrete injury. The complaint was filled with broad assertions about the capabilities of the Magnite pixel, but did not detail what personal information, if any, was actually collected from the plaintiff or how she was harmed. The court emphasized that statutory violations alone do not confer standing; plaintiffs must allege harm analogous to traditional common law privacy torts, such as intrusion upon seclusion.
The court distinguished this case from others involving more sensitive data or affirmative acts by defendants, such as ignoring explicit cookie rejections or collecting health-related information. Here, the alleged collection of an IP address and device identifiers was not deemed “highly offensive” or actionable.
Rebeka Rodriguez v. Brushfire Recs. et al., No. 2:25-CV-09797-CAS-PDX, 2025 WL 3692144 (C.D. Cal. Dec. 15, 2025).
