Judge Jesus G. Bernal, in the Central District of California, denied a motion to dismiss a class action lawsuit alleging violations of the California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA) based on the collection and transmission of users’ IP addresses and other data through website trackers. This ruling held that such practices fall within the scope of California’s pen register law and that plaintiffs can have standing to pursue claims even where the data collected is commonly shared in the course of internet use.
Plaintiffs, California residents who visited real estate websites owned by defendant, alleged that the sites installed third-party trackers (including those from TikTok, LinkedIn, and The Trade Desk) without their consent. These trackers allegedly captured users’ IP addresses and other identifying information, transmitting it to third parties for marketing and analytics purposes. Plaintiffs claimed this conduct violated CIPA, which restricts the use of “pen registers”—devices or processes that record addressing or signaling information from electronic communications.
Standing to Sue
Defendant argued that plaintiffs lacked standing because IP addresses are routinely disclosed as part of internet communications and do not carry a reasonable expectation of privacy. The court disagreed, emphasizing that the injury alleged was not the initial disclosure of IP addresses to the website, but the subsequent transmission to third parties without consent. The court also noted that the economic value of the data and its use for targeted advertising contributed to a concrete injury, sufficient to establish standing.
Scope of CIPA and Pen Register Laws
Defendant contended that CIPA’s pen register provisions were intended for telephone communications and did not apply to internet data such as IP addresses. The court rejected this narrow interpretation, finding that the statutory language is broad and encompasses “addressing” information transmitted by electronic means, including IP addresses. The court further clarified that the use of trackers to collect and transmit such information goes beyond the basic function of loading a website and may trigger CIPA liability.
Consent and Additional Data Collection
While users may consent to providing their IP address to access a website, the court distinguished this from the further retention and sharing of that information with third parties. The court also noted allegations that trackers could collect additional data, such as form inputs, strengthening the plaintiffs’ claims.
Dywanna Drummer, et al. v. CoStar Grp., Inc. Additional Party Names: Anthony D’Antonio, Cynthia Rubio, Mary Lee Wallace, Schalise Lee, No. EDCV 25-1047 JGB (SPX), 2025 WL 3190656 (C.D. Cal. Oct. 22, 2025).
