Judge Edward M. Chen, of the Northern District of California denied a motion to compel arbitration, finding the arbitration clause in an online services agreement both procedurally and substantively unconscionable.
The case arose from a putative class action alleging that a tax preparation company unlawfully intercepted and disclosed confidential taxpayer information to third parties through tracking pixels on its online platform. The company sought to compel arbitration based on an arbitration clause embedded in its Online Services Agreement (OSA), which all users were required to accept to access the platform.
Key Features of the Arbitration Agreement
- Mandatory Arbitration and Opt-Out: The OSA required all disputes to be resolved through binding individual arbitration, with a 30-day opt-out window. However, users who opted out remained bound by any prior arbitration agreements.
- Pre-Arbitration Procedures: Claimants were required to engage in an “informal resolution” process, including written notice and a 60-day settlement conference, before initiating arbitration.
- Mass Arbitration Protocol: If 25 or more claimants, represented by the same or coordinated counsel, submitted similar claims, a staged bellwether process was triggered. Only 20 cases could proceed at a time, with subsequent cases delayed until prior rounds were completed.
- Tolling Provisions: The agreement purported to toll statutes of limitation during pre-arbitration procedures, but only if a “fully complete” notice was provided—a standard left undefined and subject to the company’s interpretation.
Procedural Unconscionability
The court found the arbitration agreement procedurally unconscionable for several reasons:
- Adhesion and Lack of Negotiation: The OSA was a standard-form, non-negotiable contract presented as a condition of using the service, often during the busy tax season.
- Complexity and Surprise: The arbitration provision was buried in a dense, 21-page document, with the mass arbitration protocol and its implications unlikely to be anticipated by ordinary consumers.
With regard to the visibility and prominence of the OSA and embedded arbitration agreement, Plaintiffs allege that the OSA is a “complex, 21-page single-spaced document, drafted in small font and dense legalese that is difficult for ordinary laypersons to understand. The actual terms are not seen by website users unless one clicks on hyperlink to access the OSA.” Compl. ¶ 20. Defendants point out that, with respect to accessing the OSA, when Plaintiffs logged into their respective accounts, “they each clicked a check box next to an acknowledgement stating: I agree to the terms and conditions of the . . . Online Services Agreement. MTC at 3. Defendants state that the phrase “Online Services Agreement” was a green, underlined hyperlink immediately next to the check box. Id.; Schuessler Decl., Ex. 2. Users could not click the “Next” button at the bottom of the screen to move past the screen without first clicking the check box; instead, the screen would display a red [*9] error message requiring the user to agree to the terms and conditions, including the OSA. Id.; Schuessler Decl., Ex. 3. Defendants do not deny that the OSA itself is a 21-page single-spaced document.
…
Plaintiffs do not contest their assent to the OSA. Instead, the Plaintiffs challenge enforceability of the arbitration provision, arguing that the OSA itself, as a 21-page dense legal document, contributed to oppression and surprise and the unenforceability of the arbitration agreement.
The Court notes that the OSA does not contain a delegation provision….
- Illusory Opt-Out: The opt-out process was not a meaningful cure, as it was burdensome, required annual repetition, and was not prominently disclosed.
- Obstructive Practices: The company’s insistence on technicalities (such as requiring individual mailings of notices) and reservation of rights to challenge notices created further uncertainty and delay.
Substantive Unconscionability
The court also found the agreement substantively unconscionable:
- Systemic Delays: The mass arbitration protocol’s staged bellwether process could delay resolution of claims for years, with no effective recourse for claimants.
- Chilling Effect on Claims: The risk of protracted delays and forfeiture of claims due to ambiguous tolling provisions could deter consumers from pursuing valid claims.
- Asymmetrical Tolling: The company retained the right to challenge the adequacy of notices and the applicability of tolling, while claimants had no comparable protections.
- Inadequate Alternatives: The small claims carve-out was deemed illusory, as it did not provide a realistic or equivalent forum for complex privacy claims.
Severability
The court declined to sever the unconscionable provisions, finding that the defects permeated the entire arbitration agreement and rendered it unenforceable.
Rios v. HRB Digit. LLC, No. 25-cv-03530-EMC, 2025 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 213961 (N.D. Cal. Oct. 27, 2025).
