This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.
| 4 minute read

Court Denies Class Certification in TCPA Suit Over Promotional Texts: Individualized Issues Defeat Commonality

A recent decision from the District of Kansas denied a motion to certify a class in a Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) lawsuit involving promotional text messages sent by a vape retailer. The court found that the proposed class failed to meet the requirements for commonality and predominance under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23, primarily due to the individualized nature of determining whether each class member’s phone line qualified as “residential” under the TCPA.

Background

Plaintiff alleged that defendant, a retail vape shop, sent unsolicited promotional text messages to customers who had previously joined its rewards program. The messages were sent via third-party marketing platforms to individuals who had not made a purchase in at least ninety days. The plaintiff sought to certify a class of individuals who received more than one such message within a twelve-month period, including at least one message after making an opt-out request.

Plaintiff’s claims centered on defendant’s alleged failure to maintain adequate internal procedures for honoring do-not-call requests, as required by the TCPA and its implementing regulations. The proposed class sought statutory damages and injunctive relief.

Class Certification Analysis

  • Common Issues Identified: The court acknowledged that certain elements of the claim—such as whether the defendant sent the messages, the number of messages sent, and whether internal do-not-call procedures were in place—could be established through common, classwide evidence.

 

  • Individualized Issue: Residential Status of Phone Lines: The central obstacle to certification was the need to determine, for each class member, whether the phone number that received the messages was a “residential telephone line” as contemplated by the TCPA. The court noted that neither the statute nor its regulations define “residential,” and that the inquiry is fact-specific, especially for cell phones used for both personal and business purposes. The court found that this determination would require individualized evidence and analysis for each class member, precluding classwide adjudication.

The Tenth Circuit has not explored the distinction between a cell phone’s residential uses and its non-residential—e.g., business—ones. Other jurisdictions, however, have articulated factors that guide the inquiry. Chenette, 50 F.4th at 1225 (collecting cases). Those include “whether plaintiffs have held out to the public or advertised their phone numbers for business purposes,” “whether plaintiffs’ phones are registered with the telephone company as residential or business lines,” “whether, and the extent to which, plaintiffs use their phones for business transactions or employment,” and “whether, and the ex-tent to which, plaintiffs’ employers (or other business entities) pay for or reimburse plaintiffs for their phone bills.” Id. Those cases empha-size the fact-specific inquiry that mixed cell-phone use demands. See, e.g., Payne v. Sieva Networks, Inc., 347 F.R.D. 224, 228 (N.D. Cal. 2024); Hirsch v. USHealth Advisors, LLC, 337 F.R.D. 118, 131 (N.D. Tex. 2020); Stevens-Bratton v. TruGreen, Inc., 437 F. Supp. 3d 648, 658 (W.D. Tenn. Feb. 4, 2020).

Schmitendorf’s own phone use is a good example. At the pleading stage, Schmitendorf plausibly alleged that he was a residential tele-phone subscriber because he alleged that he registered his cell phone one the national do-not-call registry, which carries a presumption that a phone line is residential, and he alleged “that he used his cell phone only in personal contexts.” Doc. 67 at 5. That was sufficient to survive Juicy’s motion for judgment on the pleadings. Id. at 4 (citing Marks v. Unique Lifestyle Vacations, LLC, No. 20-4915, 2021 WL 5495778, at *3 (E.D. Pa. Nov. 22, 2021), and then citing Klassen v. Solid Quote LLC, No. 23-0318, 2023 WL 7544185, at *3 (D. Colo. Nov. 14, 2023)). With the benefit of discovery, however, Juicy’s has shown that Schmitendorf also uses his cell phone for business purposes. Doc. 81 at 8 (citing Doc. 73-3). For example, Schmitendorf uses his cell phone for personal communications, but he also uses it to apply for jobs, communicate with his boss, and swap shifts with his co-workers. Id. (citing Doc. 73-3).

At the certification stage, it is not necessary to decide whether Schmitendorf is indeed a residential telephone subscriber. Black, 69 F.4th at 1174 (noting that merits questions may only be considered at the certification stage to the extent that they are relevant to determine whether the Rule 23 prerequisites for class certification are satisfied). Instead, the circumstances surrounding Schmitendorf’s cell phone use demonstrate the fact-specific nature of the inquiry concerning his cell phone. See Hirsch, 337 F.R.D. at 131 (explaining that the named plain-tiff’s mixed cell-phone use provided a good example of the fact-spe-cific inquiry required to determine whether the phone line was residen-tial). That evidence involving every class member’s cell-phone use will vary, making it an individualized inquiry. That case-by-case variation precludes class treatment. Black, 69 F.4th at 1175 (noting that individ-ual issues involve evidence that varies for each class member).

  • Plaintiff’s Proposed Solutions Rejected: The plaintiff’s suggestion that class members could simply attest to the residential nature of their phone lines via affidavit was rejected, as the defendant is entitled to challenge such assertions and the inquiry is inherently fact-intensive.

Nor does Schmitendorf’s proposed solution convert the individu-alized issue into a common one. He says each class member can submit an affidavit at the class-notice stage indicating that he or she supplied Juicy’s a residential telephone number. Doc. 90 at 15. But this is insuf-ficient. The fact-specific inquiry that Juicy’s is entitled to conduct for every class member cannot be answered simply by accepting as true the class member’s subjective answer to whether or not a cell phone is residential. Juicy’s is entitled to challenge and, where appropriate, con-test such declarations. See Payne, 347 F.R.D. at 227 (noting that simply asking class members during the class notification process whether the phone line in question was a residential one would not satisfy the fact-intensive analysis required to determine whether a phone line met the TCPA’s requirements).

  • Predominance Not Established: Because the individualized inquiry into residential status was central to liability under the TCPA, the court held that common issues did not predominate, and class certification under Rule 23(b)(3) was inappropriate.

 

  • Injunctive Relief Class Also Denied: The court also denied certification under Rule 23(b)(2) for injunctive relief, finding that the plaintiff lacked standing. The defendant had ceased sending promotional messages in 2022 and presented no evidence of plans to resume, eliminating any real or immediate threat of future harm.

Brady Schmitendorf, vs. Juicy’s Vapor Lounge, Inc., No. 22-CV-02293-TC-GEB, 2025 WL 2966205 (D. Kan. Oct. 21, 2025).

Tags

residential, tcpa, telemarketing
chevron-up