This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.
| 3 minute read

Federal Court Certifies TCPA Prerecorded Call / Telemarketing Class Action

On October 20, 2025, Judge John W. Holcomb, in the Central District of California, granted class certification in a Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) action involving prerecorded calls for telemarketing. The court also denied defendant’s motion to strike the class allegations and found that defendant waived its right to compel arbitration.

Plaintiff filed suit in June 2022, alleging defendant violated the TCPA by making prerecorded telemarketing calls to consumers’ cell phones without proper consent. The class definition was refined during the litigation to include only those individuals whose numbers were obtained exclusively from LendingTree and who received a prerecorded message from defendant, as reflected in a court-ordered discovery exhibit.

Class Definition and Numerosity

  • The class is defined as all persons in the U.S. whose cell numbers appear in defendant’s discovery responses, were obtained solely via LendingTree, and who received a prerecorded call from defendant that was not returned.

 

  • The court found numerosity easily satisfied, as the class potentially includes millions of individuals.

Commonality and Typicality

  • The court identified common questions, including whether defendant made nonemergency prerecorded calls, whether it had prior express consent, and whether its conduct was knowing or willful.

 

  • The court rejected defendant’s arguments that individual issues (such as whether each class member received a voicemail or the content of each message) defeated commonality, emphasizing that the TCPA prohibits most robocalls to cell phones regardless of content.

 

  • The named plaintiff’s claims were found to be typical of the class, as they arose from the same alleged conduct.

Adequacy of Representation

  • The court determined that the plaintiff and his counsel had no conflicts with the class and were committed to vigorously prosecuting the action, as evidenced by the plaintiff’s rejection of a substantial individual settlement offer.

Predominance and Superiority

  • The court held that common questions predominate, particularly in light of the uniform nature of the alleged robocalling campaign.

 

  • Individualized issues, such as damages calculations or whether a call was returned, were not sufficient to defeat predominance.

 

  • The class action mechanism was deemed superior, given the small potential individual recoveries and the impracticality of individual suits.

Arbitration Waiver

  • Defendant argued that arbitration agreements with class members precluded class certification. The court disagreed, finding that defendant had waived its right to compel arbitration by litigating the case for two years without seeking to enforce arbitration provisions.

“[T]he test for waiver of the right to compel arbitration consists of two elements: (1) knowledge of an existing right to compel arbitration; and (2) intentional acts inconsistent with that existing right.” Hill v. Xerox Bus. Servs., LLC, 59 F.4th 457, 468 (9th Cir. 2023). “[W]aiver is a unilateral concept.” Id. at 469. “‘[T]o decide whether a [*21]  waiver has occurred, the court focuses on the actions of the person who held the right; the court seldom considers the effects of those actions on the opposing party.'” Id. (quoting Morgan v. Sundance, Inc., 596 U.S. 411, 417 (2022)). Therefore, “[a] finding of waiver by [loanDepot would] look[] only to the acts of [loanDepot], [would] bind[] only [loanDepot], [would] not reach out to affect the rights of []unnamed class members, and [would] not depend upon when the law requires or authorizes such a right to be asserted.” Id. And, as the Ninth Circuit confirmed in 2023, a class action defendant, such as loanDepot here, can waive its right to arbitrate against putative class members by failing to seek to compel arbitration in a timely manner against the named plaintiff. See id. at 469-70. loanDepot’s argument to the contrary, which cites older, out-of-circuit authorities, is unavailing.53

Kearns argues, and loanDepot does not dispute, that loanDepot noted its right to compel arbitration as an affirmative defense in the Answer that it filed in November 2022, then it proceeded to litigate this case through multiple dispositive motions without ever asserting that right.54 Indeed, loanDepot concedes that it made the “litigation choice” to decline to [*22]  seek arbitration of Kearns’s claims.55 Such “‘an intentional decision to refrain from filing a motion to compel arbitration’ . . . [to] ke[ep] the arbitrable claims in federal court for two years while seeking merits determinations,” including making Rule 12(b)(6) motions to dismiss, unmistakably constitutes a waiver of the right to compel arbitration. Id. at 471 (quoting Newirth by & through Newirth v. Aegis Senior Communities, LLC, 931 F.3d 935, 941 (9th Cir. 2019)).

Therefore, because the class members have standing and loanDepot has waived its right to compel arbitration, common questions with respect to whether loanDepot’s robocalls violated the TCPA and, if so, whether loanDepot acted knowingly and willfully, predominate.
 

Kearns v. Loandepot.Com, LLC, No. 8:22-cv-01217-JWH-JDE, 2025 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 207393 (C.D. Cal. Oct. 20, 2025).

Tags

arbitration, tcpa, telemarketing, waiver
chevron-up