This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.
| 1 minute read

Court Narrows Telemarketing Lawsuit: TCPA and Negligence Claims Dismissed, Others Proceed

A recent decision from the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois clarified the scope of liability for telemarketing calls under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) and addressed the viability of related negligence claims under Illinois law.

Do-Not-Call Requests: Some Claims Survive

Plaintiffs alleged that they received multiple telemarketing calls promoting insurance products, including calls to numbers listed on the national do-not-call registry and calls made after explicit requests not to be contacted further. The court allowed claims to proceed where plaintiffs plausibly alleged that do-not-call requests were made to agents acting on behalf of the defendant companies. The court emphasized that liability for failing to honor do-not-call requests can extend to all affiliated entities if a reasonable consumer would expect them to be included, especially where the companies present themselves as a unified group.

Prerecorded Voice Call Claims Dismissed

The court dismissed claims based on the use of a prerecorded or artificial voice during a call that was otherwise initiated by a live operator. The court interpreted the TCPA’s prohibition on calls “using an artificial or prerecorded voice” as applying only to calls initiated with such technology, not to live calls where a prerecorded message is played incidentally (e.g., during a failed call transfer). This interpretation narrows the potential liability for businesses using live operators, even if a prerecorded message is triggered during the call.

Negligence and Recordkeeping: Spoliation Claim Dismissed

Plaintiffs also asserted a negligence claim, arguing that the defendants failed to preserve telemarketing records as required by the Telemarketing Sales Rule (TSR), which they claimed would hinder their ability to prove TCPA violations. While the court recognized that the TSR can create a duty to preserve certain records, it dismissed the claim because plaintiffs did not adequately allege that any relevant records were actually lost or destroyed. The court left open the possibility for plaintiffs to amend their complaint if they can show actual spoliation and resulting harm.

Motion to Strike Allegations Denied

Defendants sought to strike certain allegations regarding calls outside the relevant statutory period. The court denied this request, finding that such allegations could provide useful factual context or relate to the timing of do-not-call requests.

Moore v. Farmers Grp., Inc., No. 23-cv-16587, 2025 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 205986 (N.D. Ill. Oct. 20, 2025).

Tags

tcpa, telemarketing
chevron-up