In Crowell v. Audible Inc., the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington dismissed claims brought under California privacy law against Audible Inc., finding that a valid choice-of-law clause required application of Washington law. The court granted plaintiffs leave to amend their complaint to assert claims under Washington law, underscoring the importance of contractual terms in online service agreements.
Plaintiffs, California residents and Audible subscribers, alleged that Audible used the Meta Pixel tracking tool to collect and share their audiobook browsing and listening data with Meta (Facebook) without their consent. This data sharing was purportedly used to generate targeted advertising. Plaintiffs claimed these actions violated the California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA) and the California Constitution.
A tracking pixel “is a piece of JavaScript code added to a website” that “is loaded when a user lands on the website hosting it.” Id. ¶ 42. When someone visits a website hosting a tracking pixel, the pixel loads a library of functions that the website’s operator can use to track actions taken on the website. Id. ¶¶ 42–43. For the duration of the visit, the tracking pixel logs and reports the user’s actions along with a “specific ID” that allows the actions to be identified with a “specific website user.” Id. ¶ 42 (citation modified).
Crowell and Smith allege that audible.com hosts a tracking pixel (the “MetaPixel”) that Meta offers its advertising customers, including Audible. Id. ¶ 51. Meta’s customers use MetaPixel to learn how users are interacting with their websites and to generate marketing that targets users based, in part, on those interactions. When a user attempts to visit audible.com, MetaPixel causes two sets of code to run in the background: Audible’s own code and “[Meta’s] embedded code,” which “directs the user’s browser to … send a separate message to [Meta’s] servers.” Id. ¶ 50. While users browse and interact with audiobooks on audible.com, MetaPixel transmits information about those actions to Meta’s servers. For instance, “[w]hen a user views an audiobook,” Audible “discloses to [Meta] through the [Meta] Pixel the audiobook that the user viewed,” including the book’s title and a unique Amazon identification number that can be used to pinpoint the exact version of the book. Id. ¶¶ 60–63. If the user has a Facebook account, MetaPixel also transmits a set of “cookies” that identify the user’s “Facebook ID,” which is “a string of numbers unique to every Facebook account.” Id. ¶¶ 64–65, 66, 72–73, 75, 80. Using the Facebook ID, Meta matches activity on audible.com with specific Facebook users.
*2Meta and Audible use information about user activity gathered by MetaPixel to generate and evaluate targeted advertising. For instance, Meta and Audible “track[ ] website visitors’ actions” to analyze the effectiveness of Audible’s ongoing marketing efforts and identify individuals more likely to be interested in particular ads. Id. ¶¶ 84–85, 89. Audible also uses a Meta service called “Advantage+[,]” which enables Audible to “create thousands of ads” that “target visitors based on how they have interacted with [audible.com] in the past[,]” “without having to configure each [ad] individually[.]” Id. ¶ 86.
Choice-of-Law
Central to the court’s decision was the existence of a broad choice-of-law provision in Amazon’s Conditions of Use, which governs disputes involving Audible (an Amazon subsidiary). The court found that:
- Plaintiffs had reasonable notice of, and assented to, the Conditions of Use each time they signed in to their Audible accounts.
- The Audible Conditions of Use clearly incorporated Amazon’s Conditions of Use, including the Washington choice-of-law provision.
- The choice-of-law clause was enforceable, as applying Washington law did not violate a fundamental public policy of California.
The court rejected plaintiffs’ arguments that the clause was inconspicuous or that its enforcement would undermine California’s privacy protections. Notably, the court distinguished this case from others where choice-of-law provisions were invalidated due to explicit legislative findings or fundamental policy statements, such as those found in Illinois’ Biometric Information Privacy Act.
Conflict Between California and Washington Law
The court acknowledged a substantive difference between California’s CIPA and Washington’s Privacy Act (WPA). While CIPA broadly prohibits interception of communications without consent, the WPA, as interpreted by recent federal decisions, does not extend to communications between an individual and a business’s automated system (such as a website). Despite this conflict, the court held that the difference did not rise to the level of a fundamental policy that would override the parties’ contractual choice of law.
Crowell v. Audible Inc., No. C25-0606-KKE, 2025 WL 2939260 (W.D. Wash. Oct. 16, 2025).
