This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.
| 3 minute read

Court Dismisses for Lack of Personal Jurisdiction and Transfers TCPA Class Action to Washington

The Northern District of Illinois dismissed claims against a Washington-based defendant for lack of personal jurisdiction and ordered the transfer of the entire action to the Western District of Washington. The case involved allegations of unwanted telemarketing under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) and Washington state law, with the court’s analysis focusing on jurisdictional and venue considerations.

Personal Jurisdiction Over Out-of-State Defendant

The plaintiff, a Washington resident, brought a putative class action against an Illinois-based manufacturer and its Washington-based dealer, alleging receipt of unsolicited telemarketing messages. The Washington dealer moved to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction or, alternatively, to transfer venue.

The court found that the Washington dealer did not have sufficient minimum contacts with Illinois to justify personal jurisdiction. The plaintiff’s arguments—relying on the existence of a dealership agreement with the Illinois manufacturer and the alleged orchestration of marketing activities from Illinois—were unpersuasive. The court emphasized that the relevant conduct (sending and receiving the messages) occurred in Washington, and the mere purchase of products from an Illinois company or the existence of a forum selection clause in an agreement to which the plaintiff was not a party did not establish jurisdiction.

Regarding consent, a non-signatory to an agreement may enforce forum selection clauses only if it possesses “an ‘affiliation’ or mutuality’ with a contracting party.” United Airlines, Inc. v. Zaman, 152 F. Supp. 3d 1041, 1054 (N.D. Ill. 2015) (quoting Adams v. Raintree Vacation Exchange, LLC, 702 F.3d 436, 439 (7th Cir. 2012)). “Affiliation means that the non-signatory shares a corporate relationship with a signatory,” such as parents and their subsidiaries, while mutuality is the “principle that if a signatory can enforce the forum selection clause against a non-signatory, then the non-signatory should be allowed to do the same.” Id. Neither is true here; Hoffman is neither affiliated with BP Seattle nor in contract with it. Though he argues that Am. Patriot Ins. Agency, Inc. v. Mutual Risk Mgmt. Ltd., 364 F.3d 884 (7th Cir. 2004), permits non-parties to invoke forum selection clauses “if the dispute is closely related to the agreement containing that clause,” he misreads the case. [Dkt. 22 at 6.] Am. Patriot Ins. Agency, Inc. presents a classic example of affiliation: a signatory plaintiff sought to sidestep a forum selection clause with one company by suing its non-signatory affiliate. Id. at 889. It cannot be read to permit a non-signatory plaintiff to enforce a forum selection clause among corporate affiliates.

Hoffman is also incorrect in arguing that, through its relationship with Bath Planet, BP Seattle purposefully availed itself of the privilege of conducting business in Illinois. As an initial matter, TCPA claims (and their state analogs) are “considered an intentional tort for jurisdictional purposes.” Woodward v. Humana Inc., 2024 WL 1363713, at *2 (N.D. Ill. Mar. 29, 2024). Thus, the issue is not purposeful availment, which is commonly a breach-of-contract inquiry, but whether “the conduct underlying the claims was purposely directed at the forum state.” Tamburo v. Dworkin, 601 F.3d 693, 702 (7th Cir. 2010). See also Felland v. Clifton, 682 F.3d 665, 674 (7th Cir. 2012) (observing that “the purposeful-direction/purposeful-availment inquiry depends in large part on the type of claim at issue” and pressing the corresponding “tort-vs.-contract distinction”). The contract cases that Hoffman cites, which generally involve suits between contract signatories, are inapposite.

Transfer of Venue

Upon finding a lack of personal jurisdiction, the court considered whether to transfer the case in the interest of justice. The court determined that transfer to the Western District of Washington was appropriate under both 28 U.S.C. § 1631 and § 1404(a), citing judicial efficiency and the concentration of relevant parties and activities in Washington.

The court’s analysis of convenience and the interests of justice included:

  • Minimal deference to the plaintiff’s choice of forum, as the plaintiff was not an Illinois resident and the events were centered in Washington.

 

  • Where material events occurred, including both the sending and receipt of the alleged messages in Washington.

 

  • The convenience of witnesses and parties favored Washington, as all relevant personnel for the Washington dealer were based there, and the plaintiff resided in Washington.

 

  • The Western District of Washington had a less congested docket and a faster time to trial compared to the Northern District of Illinois.

 

  • The local interest in enforcing Washington’s consumer protection laws was stronger in Washington.

Mark Hoffman, v. BCI Acrylic, LLC d/b/a Bath Planet & Nw. Bath Specialists, LLC d/b/a Bath Planet of Seattle, No. 25 CV 6107, 2025 WL 2896821 (N.D. Ill. Oct. 10, 2025).

Tags

personal jurisdiction, tcpa
chevron-up