In the Northern District of California, Judge Rita F. Lin, granted a motion to compel arbitration in a privacy class action, finding that users of a food delivery app were bound by arbitration agreements with the app provider, even when suing a non-signatory analytics company.
- Standing for Privacy Claims Upheld: The court rejected arguments that the plaintiffs lacked standing, finding that allegations of unauthorized collection and dissemination of sensitive personal data—such as geolocation, device identifiers, and in-app activity—constituted a concrete privacy harm.
Plaintiffs allege that their private information—e.g., timestamped geolocation information, device IDs, device fingerprint data, information about other apps they were using on their device, search terms input to the app, products placed in their cart, and other restaurants and products they viewed—was collected and disseminated. (Compl. ¶¶ 34, 38.) Furthermore, Plaintiffs allege that the collection of this data “may reveal, for instance, a consumer’s religious affiliation, sexual orientation, medical condition, and even whether the consumer is part of an at-risk population.” (Id. ¶ 27.) Disclosure of facts that allegedly reveal this highly sensitive information is sufficient to allege a concrete privacy harm analogous to those actionable under common law privacy torts. See Popa v. Microsoft Corp., No. 24-cv-00014, 2025 WL 2448824, at *6, *8 (9th Cir. Aug. 26, 2025) (recognizing the continuing viability of In re Facebook based on the alleged compilation of “personally identifiable browsing history” that was tracked “no matter how sensitive” the content was).
Moreover, assuming without deciding that consent is pertinent to the standing inquiry, Plaintiffs have sufficiently alleged that they did not consent to the dissemination of their private information to Amplitude. Although DoorDash’s Privacy Policy2 discloses that DoorDash may share the information it collects from users with service providers, including those that support its marketing and analytics, Plaintiffs are alleging that Amplitude used the information for its own purposes—which is conduct plausibly alleged to be beyond the scope of Plaintiffs’ consent. Thus, because Plaintiffs have sufficiently alleged that they suffered a concrete and particularized privacy injury, they have Article III standing to assert their claims.
- Arbitration Agreements Can Bind Users to Non-Signatories: The court held that the plaintiffs, users of a food delivery app, were required to arbitrate their claims against a third-party analytics provider based on arbitration agreements they accepted with the app provider. This was achieved through the doctrine of equitable estoppel, given the close relationship between the claims and the underlying contract.
- Equitable Estoppel Doctrine Applied: The court found both prongs of California’s equitable estoppel doctrine satisfied: (1) the plaintiffs’ claims were intimately connected to the app provider’s privacy policy and terms, and (2) the alleged misconduct was interdependent between the app provider and the analytics company.
- Arbitration Agreement Not Unconscionable: The court determined that the arbitration agreement, including its delegation and batch arbitration provisions, was not unconscionable. Users had the opportunity to opt out, and the agreement’s procedures for handling mass claims were found to be fair and efficient.
Atkins v. Amplitude, Inc., No. 24-CV-04913-RFL, 2025 WL 2521732 (N.D. Cal. Sept. 2, 2025).
