On August 18, 2025, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals addressed the enforceability of online arbitration agreements in the context of privacy litigation. The court reviewed de novo and reversed a district court’s denial of a motion to compel arbitration in a case involving claims under the Video Privacy Protection Act (VPPA).
- Reasonably Conspicuous Notice: The Ninth Circuit held that defendant’s website provided “reasonably conspicuous” notice of its Terms of Service, which included an arbitration clause. The court emphasized that the hyperlink to the terms was displayed in a bright blue font against a white background, located directly above the “Start subscription” button, and accompanied by a clear statement that clicking below signified agreement to the terms. The court found these features sufficient to alert a reasonably prudent user to the existence of contractual terms.
- Context Matters: The court noted that the context of a recurring subscription service further supports the expectation that users would scrutinize the website for contractual terms, reinforcing the adequacy of the notice provided.
- Assent and Remaining Issues: While the appellate court found the notice to be sufficient, it remanded the case for the district court to address unresolved questions, including whether the plaintiff unambiguously manifested assent to the terms, the scope of the arbitration clause, and whether certain parties could enforce the agreement.
