The California Supreme Court addressed whether California’s statutes requiring timely payment of arbitration fees by employers or companies are preempted by the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA). Holding: while California law imposes strict deadlines for payment of arbitration fees, non-willful, excusable delays do not automatically result in forfeiture of the right to arbitrate. The Court’s decision harmonizes state contract law principles with federal arbitration policy, providing important guidance for businesses, employees, and consumers engaged in arbitration.
- California’s Arbitration Fee Statutes Not Preempted by FAA: The Court held that Code of Civil Procedure section 1281.98, which requires the drafting party (typically the employer or company) to pay arbitration fees within 30 days of the due date, is not preempted by the FAA. The statute is consistent with general contract law and does not single out arbitration agreements for disfavored treatment.
- Excusable Delay May Avoid Forfeiture: The Court rejected a rigid interpretation of section 1281.98 that would result in automatic loss of arbitration rights for any late payment. Instead, it held that longstanding contract law principles—such as excusable neglect, impossibility, or other equitable doctrines—can excuse non-willful or inadvertent delays, provided the non-breaching party is adequately compensated for any harm.
- Remand for Fact-Specific Inquiry: The case was remanded to the trial court to determine whether the employer’s delay in paying arbitration fees was excusable and whether the delay caused compensable harm to the employee. This fact-specific inquiry aligns with general contract law, which considers the circumstances and good faith of the parties.
- Legislative Intent and Policy: The Court recognized that the Legislature enacted these statutes to deter strategic nonpayment and delay tactics by companies, particularly in employment and consumer arbitrations. However, the statutes were not intended to penalize good faith mistakes or minor, excusable errors.
- Flexibility for Parties: Parties remain free to contract for alternative payment deadlines or to agree to extensions, preserving flexibility in arbitration agreements.
Hohenshelt v. Superior Ct. of Los Angeles Cnty., 18 Cal. 5th 310 (2025).
