The U.S. District Court for the District of Arizona addresses two post-trial motions in a class action lawsuit involving alleged violations of the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA). The court required the defendant to post a supersedeas bond of $168,225,000 to stay execution of a substantial class judgment pending appeal and denied, without prejudice, the defendant’s motion to decertify the class due to lack of jurisdiction.
The litigation stems from claims that the defendant obtained consumer credit reports without a permissible purpose, in violation of the FCRA. The class was certified to include over 56,000 individuals whose credit reports were accessed via the defendant’s ecommerce website between November 2012 and November 2014, provided they had not signed arbitration agreements or class action waivers.
Following a jury trial, the defendant was found liable and the jury awarded $500 in statutory damages and $2,000 in punitive damages per class member. The court subsequently clarified that the judgment applied to all 56,075 individuals who received class notice and did not opt out.
Supersedeas Bond Requirement
The defendant sought to stay execution of the judgment during its appeal by posting a bond of $85 million, arguing that the actual number of qualifying class members would likely be lower after a claims administration process. The plaintiff countered that a bond covering 120% of the total potential damages—$168,225,000—was necessary to protect class members’ interests. The court sided with the plaintiff, focusing on the fact that defendant had identified the class list and had ample opportunity to challenge class membership prior to judgment.
Defendant, as the party in possession of information about the individuals who it collected credit reports on and who did not sign a class action or arbitration waiver, has had multiple chances to identify which of the 56,075 individuals who received class notice as potential class members do not actually fall within the class definition. Defendant has thus far identified a single individual.2 (Doc. 266 at 6–7). While this Court has acknowledged that a claims administration process is appropriate to ensure that non-class members do not receive damages (Doc. 287 at 5), the Court is dubious that the class size will be reduced by half through this process. As such, the Court finds it inappropriate to require a supersedeas bond that amounts to approximately half of the judgment should the class size remain the same. Instead, in its discretion, the Court will require Defendant to post a supersedeas bond totaling 120 percent of the potential damages calculated based on the proposed 56,075-individual class list. This amounts to $168,225,000.00.
Class Decertification Motion
After the trial, the defendant moved to decertify the class. However, because the defendant had already filed a notice of appeal, the court determined it lacked jurisdiction to rule on the decertification motion. The motion was therefore denied without prejudice, leaving the issue open for potential future consideration if jurisdiction returns to the district court.
Bultemeyer v. CenturyLink Inc., No. CV-14-02530-PHX-SPL, 2025 WL 2337097 (D. Ariz. Aug. 13, 2025).
