In a recent decision from the Northern District of California, Judge Araceli Martínez-Olguín granted an SDK provider’s motion to compel arbitration, finding that the consumer was bound by the app’s terms of service and that the SDK provider could enforce the arbitration agreement as a third-party beneficiary under equitable estoppel principles.
The plaintiff, a user of a mobile application, brought claims under federal and California privacy statutes, alleging that the app’s embedded SDK collected sensitive user data—including search terms, keystrokes, and personal information—without proper disclosure or consent.
- Existence of a Valid Arbitration Agreement
The court first examined whether a valid arbitration agreement existed between the plaintiff and the app developer. Applying California contract law, the court found that the app’s onboarding process provided reasonably conspicuous notice of the terms of service and privacy policy. The user was required to affirmatively agree to these terms by tapping a “Continue” button, which the court classified as a “sign-in wrap” agreement. The court determined that the design and placement of the notice were sufficient to put a reasonably prudent user on inquiry notice, and that the plaintiff’s actions unambiguously manifested assent to the terms, including the arbitration provision.
The Welcome Page features a deep blue background, and in contrasting white font states “Create an account to save your progress.” (Id. ¶ 9.) Below that statement are three buttons, each of which say “Continue” and present different methods of creating an account—with email, with Facebook, or with Google. (Id.)
…
Immediately below the three buttons, in the same white font as the initial statement, the page provides the following advisal of terms: “By tapping Continue or logging into an existing Calm account, you agree to our Terms and acknowledge that you have read our Privacy Policy, which explains how to opt out of offers and promos.” (Id. ¶¶ 9-10.) The underlined words are hyperlinked….
- Enforceability by a Non-Signatory (SDK Provider)
The central question was whether the SDK provider, not a signatory to the agreement, could enforce the arbitration clause. The court held that under California’s doctrine of equitable estoppel, a non-signatory may compel arbitration when the plaintiff’s claims are “intimately founded in and intertwined with” the underlying contract. Here, the plaintiff’s claims of unauthorized data collection depended on whether the app’s terms and privacy policy authorized such data sharing with third parties like the SDK provider. The court found that the privacy policy explicitly addressed sharing user information with service providers, making the claims inseparable from the contractual terms.
The court rejected the plaintiff’s arguments that the privacy policy was not incorporated into the terms of service, and that the agreement’s language limiting third-party beneficiary rights precluded enforcement by the SDK provider. The court clarified that equitable estoppel is a distinct doctrine from third-party beneficiary status and applies where fairness requires enforcement of the arbitration agreement.
Bender v. Twilio Inc., No. 24-CV-04914-AMO, 2025 WL 2308484, at *2 (N.D. Cal. Aug. 11, 2025).
