This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.
| 1 minute read

California Supreme Court Upholds State Arbitration Fee Law Against FAA Preemption Challenge

On August 11, 2025, the California Supreme Court held that section 1281.98—which requires the party drafting an employment or consumer arbitration agreement to pay arbitration fees within 30 days of the due date or risk losing the right to compel arbitration—is not preempted by the FAA. The Court interpreted the statute to allow relief for good faith, inadvertent, or excusable delays in payment, aligning the law with general contract principles and mitigating concerns about inflexible forfeiture of arbitration rights.

  • Section 1281.98 is not preempted by the FAA, provided it is construed to allow relief for excusable neglect, mistake, or other good faith reasons for late payment.
  • The statute’s default rule requires timely payment of arbitration fees but does not override longstanding legal principles that excuse nonperformance in appropriate circumstances.
  • The decision disapproves prior appellate decisions that interpreted section 1281.98 as imposing a strict, “no-exceptions” rule.
  • The case is remanded for the trial court to determine whether the employer’s late payment was excusable and whether any compensable harm resulted.

Statutory Construction and Legislative Intent

According to the Court, section 1281.98 was enacted to address the problem of employers and companies strategically withholding arbitration fees to delay or derail employee and consumer claims. However, the Court rejected a rigid interpretation of the statute, finding no evidence that the Legislature intended to penalize inadvertent or excusable delays.

The Court harmonized section 1281.98 with background California statutes and contract law principles, including Civil Code sections 3275 (relief from forfeiture for excusable neglect), 1511 (excuse for impossibility or impracticability), and Code of Civil Procedure section 473(b) (relief for mistake or excusable neglect). The Court concluded that these principles remain available to parties who miss payment deadlines for reasons other than willful, grossly negligent, or fraudulent conduct.

FAA Preemption

The Court held that, “properly construed,” section 1281.98 does not violate the FAA’s “equal-treatment principle,” which prohibits states from singling out arbitration agreements for disfavored treatment. The statute, as interpreted, applies general contract defenses and does not impose unique burdens on arbitration agreements. The Court also found that the law does not interfere with the fundamental attributes of arbitration, such as party autonomy and streamlined procedures, because parties remain free to contract for different payment timelines and to seek relief from forfeiture in appropriate cases.

Hohenshelt v. Superior Ct. of Los Angeles Cnty., 18 Cal. 5th 310 (2025).

Tags

arbitration, arbitration fees, faa preemption
chevron-up