This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.
| 2 minute read

District Court (CA) Finds Repossession Company Falls Under FDCPA/Rosenthal Act; Defines What Constitutes a Breach of the Peace

In DOUGLAS GALANTER, Plaintiff, v. ACCESS FINANCE, INC. et al., Defendants. Additional Party Names: Juan Martinez, Los Angeles Auto Wholesalers & Recovery Servs., Inc., Steven McIntosh, No. 2:23-CV-09466-ODW (SSCX), 2025 WL 2172193, at *4 (C.D. Cal. July 31, 2025), Judge Wright defined summary judgment to a repossession company, finding a triable issue of fact. First, Judge Wright found that the repossession company fell under the FDCPA.

The parties do not dispute that LAW Recovery is a repossession company. (Mot. 5; Opp’n 9.) Repossession activities are “a form of security-interest enforcement, as the point of repossessing property that secures a debt is to collect some or all of the value of the defaulted debt.” Obduskey v. McCarthy & Holthus LLP, 586 U.S. 466, 478 (2019). A repossession company therefore falls within the definition of “debt collector” for the purposes of § 1692f(6). See Pflueger, 1999 WL 33740813, at *4 (“It thus appears that Congress intended an enforcer of a security interest, such as a repossession company, to fall outside the ambit of the FDCPA except for the provisions of § 1692f(6).” (emphasis added)); Clark v. PAR Inc., No. 2:15-cv-02322-MWF (FFMx), 2015 WL 13781846, at *3 (C.D. Cal. July 22, 2015) (finding defendant, a repossession forwarder, is a debt collector for purposes of § 1692f(6)). Accordingly, as LAW Recovery is a repossession company, it comes under the FDCPA’s limited purpose definition of “debt collector” under § 1692f(6). Summary judgment is therefore denied as to this basis.

Second, Judge Wright defined what constitutes a breach of the peace under California law, and whether a threat of violence is required.

LAW Recovery also argues that it did not breach the peace by violating California Business and Professions Code section 7508.2(d) because McIntosh entered the garage while the gate was open and Galanter did not own the garage or reside at the South Springpark Avenue address. (Mot. 11.) To the extent LAW Recovery argues that Galanter’s lack of ownership defeats this claim, this argument is unavailing. LAW Recovery cites to the elements of a trespass claim to support this argument. (Id.) But Business and Professions Code section 7508.2 does not specify that the private building or secured area must be owned by the plaintiff. Instead, it generally prohibits the unlawful entry onto “any private building or secured area without the consent of the owner, or of the person in legal possession thereof, at the time of repossession.” Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code § 7508.2(d). Here, LAW Recovery argues Galanter never resided at the South Springpark Avenue address. (Mot. 11.) But LAW Recovery does not present any evidence to show that McIntosh had the condominium building owner’s consent to access the gated garage on the day of the repossession. As described above, a breach of the peace may occur if “force or threats of force are necessary.” Hartford, 96 Cal. App. 3d at 600. Courts in this district have found entry onto a gated or secured property without permission sufficient to create an issue as to whether defendants breached the peace. See, e.g., Rivin, 2020 WL 8365251, at *4 (finding the plaintiff sufficiently pleaded a claim under § 1692f(6) by alleging defendants breached the peace when they entered his property, secured by a locked gate and fence, without permission); Clark, 2015 WL 13781846, at *5–6 (same).
Here, there is a genuine dispute of material fact as to whether LAW Recovery breached the peace when it entered the gated garage. It is undisputed that the Vehicle was parked in a gated garage secured by a mechanized metal gate.

 

Tags

legal updates
chevron-up