Judge Todd W. Robinson in the Southern District of California denied a retailer’s motion to compel arbitration in a consumer class action, finding that the website’s arbitration agreement was not sufficiently conspicuous or binding on the purchaser.
The plaintiff filed a class action alleging violations of California’s false advertising and consumer protection statutes after purchasing a discounted product from the retailer’s website. The retailer sought to compel arbitration, arguing that the plaintiff agreed to its Terms of Use—including a binding arbitration clause—by completing the online purchase.
The website’s checkout process included a statement above the “Place Order” button: “By clicking ‘Place Order’ you agree to J.Jill’s Terms of Use & Privacy Policy,” with “Terms of Use” as a blue, underlined hyperlink. The arbitration provision was highlighted at the top of the Terms of Use page.
The court analyzed whether the plaintiff had actual or constructive notice of the arbitration agreement, applying California contract law principles and recent Ninth Circuit guidance on online contract formation. The court considered both the visual design of the website and the context of the transaction.
- Visual Conspicuousness: The notice was in a smaller font than surrounding elements but was not illegible or obscured. The hyperlink was blue and underlined, consistent with standard web conventions.

- Placement: The notice appeared directly below the “Place Order” button, a location generally favored by courts for providing notice.
- Transaction Context: The plaintiff completed the purchase as a guest, without creating an account or entering into an ongoing relationship with the retailer. The court found this context less likely to put a consumer on notice that they were agreeing to binding terms, including arbitration.
Here, it is undisputed that Plaintiff did not create an account with Defendant, electing instead to check out as a “guest.” (See Cody Decl. ¶ 2.) This context distinguishes this case from those in which the Ninth Circuit has found that the context of the transaction would put a user on inquiry notice that use of a company’s website or services constituted an agreement to its terms and conditions, including an arbitration provision. Cf., e.g., Keebaugh, 100 F.4th at 1020 (concluding that context of transaction was sufficient to put
users on inquiry notice where users were downloading mobile game onto phone because “the entire point of the download is to have continued access to play the game”); Oberstein, 60 F.4th at 517 (“[T]he context of this transaction, requiring a full registration process, reflected the contemplation of ‘some sort of continuing relationship’ that would have put users on notice for a link to the terms of that continuing relationship.” (citing Sellers, 73 Cal. App. 5th at 480)); cf. also Lawrence v. Finicity Corp., No. 24-1737, _ Fed. App’x _, 2025 WL 547375, at *2 (9th Cir. Feb. 19, 2025) (reversing district court’s denial of motion to compel arbitration because, “[o]nce alerted to [the defendant]’s role in the transaction, a reasonable consumer would expect to have a continuing, forward-looking
relationship with the entity they are entrusting with their bank data to track their account over time” (internal quotation marks omitted) (quoting Keebaugh, 100 F.4th at 1017)). Indeed, this case most closely resembles Sellers, in which the California Court of Appeal
noted that “most consumers would not expect to be bound by contractual terms” when engaging in a “trivial” transaction like “the sale of a single item, such as a pair of socks.” See 73 Cal. App. 5th at 464–65. The context of the transaction therefore weighs against
concluding that Plaintiff was sufficiently aware that, by placing an order through jjill.com, she would be entering into an agreement including an arbitration provision.
Despite the relatively clear visual presentation, the court concluded that, in the context of a one-time retail purchase, the notice was not sufficiently conspicuous to bind the plaintiff to the arbitration agreement. The court emphasized that website owners bear the burden of putting users on clear notice of any terms they wish to enforce.
Cody v. Jill Acquisition LLC, 3:25-cv-00937 (S.D. Cal. June 30, 2025).
