This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.
| 5 minute read

Class Rep Fails to Allege That the Alleged Privacy Violations Occurred While She was Located in California

Judge Gonzalo P. Curiel, of the Southern District of California, grants in part and denies in part the defendant’s motions to dismiss. Plaintiff is compelled to proceed using her real name.

The plaintiff, representing a putative class, alleges that the telehealth provider’s website embedded Google Analytics and TikTok Pixel on pages where users enter personally identifiable information (PII) and protected health information (PHI). These technologies allegedly intercepted and transmitted sensitive data—including names, medical conditions, and health histories—to Google and TikTok in real time. The complaint asserts that this data was used not only to improve the provider’s advertising but also aggregated by the third parties for their own commercial purposes, such as targeted advertising and consumer profiling. The decision addresses privacy and jurisdictional issues.

Jurisdictional Challenges: Standing and Personal Jurisdiction

Defendant moved to dismiss the case for lack of subject matter jurisdiction, lack of personal jurisdiction, and failure to state a claim. The court found that the plaintiff had sufficiently alleged an injury-in-fact for Article III standing, based on the alleged invasion of privacy and unauthorized disclosure of sensitive information.

According to the complaint, when patients visit the website, once they click on their medical condition, they are prompted to answer a number of intake questions asking for personal information, including “their full name, gender, height, weight, symptoms, dates of exposure for certain contagious diseases and sexually transmitted infections, pregnancy status, breastfeeding status, medications, and surgical history.” (Id. ¶¶ 22-25.) Only when all the personal and health information are entered can patients can make a telehealth appointment and enter their payment information to purchase the service or tests. (Id. ¶ 26.) Plaintiff alleges she sought treatment for an upper respiratory infection and afterwards, she began receiving targeted advertisement related to pneumonia treatment on Google and other internet sites. (Id. ¶¶ 5, 7.)

However, the court determined that the plaintiff failed to adequately allege that the relevant conduct occurred while she was physically present in California—a necessary element for establishing specific personal jurisdiction and for claims under California’s privacy statutes.

he complaint also alleges generally that “Defendant, when aiding and assisting the wiretapping, which occurred in California, intended to help Google and TikTok learn some meaning of the content in the URLs, the answers to intake questions, and the content the visitor requested.” (Id. ¶ 76.) These two allegations do not create a reasonable inference that Plaintiff was in California when she accessed Defendant’s website seeking treatment in 2023 or 2024.

The court granted the motion to dismiss on this ground, but allowed the plaintiff leave to amend the complaint to address this deficiency.

California Privacy Claims: CIPA and CMIA

The plaintiff’s claims under the California Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA) and the California Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (CMIA) were scrutinized in detail:

The Supreme Court of California has explained section 631(a) as “three distinct and mutually independent patterns of conduct: [1] intentional wiretapping, [2] willfully attempting to learn the contents or meaning of a communication in transit over a wire, and [3] attempting to use or communicate information obtained as a result of engaging in either of the previous two activities.” Tavernetti v. Superior Ct. of San Diego Cnty., 22 Cal. 3d 187, 192 (1978). In addition, “Section 631(a) … contains a fourth basis for liability, for anyone ‘who aids, agrees with, employs, or conspires with any person or persons to unlawfully do, or permit, or cause to be done any of the’ other three bases for liability.” Mastel v. Miniclip SA, 549 F. Supp. 3d 1129, 1134 (E.D. Cal. 2021) (quoting Cal. Penal Code § 631(a).) The fourth clause of section 631(a) depends on establishing a violation of the first, second, or third clauses. Id. at 1137; see Esparza v. UAG Escondido A1 Inc., Case No. 23cv0102 DMS(KSC), 2024 WL 559241, at *2 (S.D. Cal. Feb. 12, 2024) (“To state a claim under this clause, Plaintiff must allege [LivePerson] has violated one of the first three clauses of section 631(a), and that Defendant aided, agreed with, employed, or conspired with that person or entity to commit those unlawful acts.”).

  • CIPA: The court dismissed claims under the first and second clauses of CIPA section 631(a) (intentional wiretapping and eavesdropping by a party to the communication), but allowed the claim to proceed under the fourth clause, which imposes liability for aiding and abetting third-party eavesdropping. The court found that the plaintiff plausibly alleged that Google and TikTok acted as third-party eavesdroppers, intercepting communications in real time for their own purposes, and that the defendant could be liable for aiding this conduct.

The question here is whether Google and TikTok are third-party eavesdroppers engaged in simultaneous listening in as in Ribas, or whether their conduct is equivalent of a tape-recorder used to record a conversation which is later played back to a third party, as in Rogers.

The complaint alleges Defendant violated CIPA by aiding and assisting Google and TikTok to simultaneously to track, intercept and receive patients’ PII and PHI through its website. (Dkt. No. 1, Compl. ¶¶ 2, 6, 75-77, 79.) Plaintiff alleges Defendant intentionally embedded and installed Google Analytics and TikTok Pixel on its website where users enter PII and PHI. (Id. ¶¶ 33, 52.) Google and TikTok intercepted, in real time, Plaintiff’s PII and PHI, processed and assembled that information into data sets for purposes of advertising. (Id. ¶ 56.) The Court finds that Plaintiff’s allegations are akin to the conduct in Ribas because Plaintiff alleges that Google and TikTok intercepted communications in real time, or in other words, they simultaneously listened in on the communications between Plaintiff and Defendant.

…

Unlike the plaintiffs’ allegations in Graham and Licea, Plaintiff present facts that Google and TikTok use her intercepted communication for purposes other than just to benefit Defendant.

  • CMIA: The court dismissed the CMIA claim for failure to allege that the conduct occurred in California, but found that the telehealth provider could qualify as a “provider of health care” under the statute, and that the plaintiff had sufficiently alleged the disclosure of “medical information.”

Common Law and Constitutional Privacy Claims

The court also addressed claims for invasion of privacy under the California Constitution and the common law tort of intrusion upon seclusion. While the court dismissed these claims for failure to allege conduct in California, it found that the plaintiff had sufficiently alleged the disclosure of specific, sensitive personal information and a serious invasion of privacy interest.

For an intrusion upon seclusion, “the defendant must intentionally intrude into a place, conversation, or matter as to which the plaintiff has a reasonable expectation of privacy.” Hernandez, 47 Cal. 4th 272 at 286. While Plaintiff voluntarily shared her personal and medical information with Defendant, she alleges Defendant intentionally disclosed her medical information with Google and TikTok by intercepting it. (Dkt. No. 1, Compl. ¶¶ 2, 6, 36, 56.) Plaintiff plausibly alleges an intrusion upon seclusion claim, and the Court DENIES Defendant’s motion to dismiss on this ground.

Requirement to Proceed Under Real Name

The court granted the defendant’s motion to compel compliance with Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 10(a), requiring the plaintiff to proceed under her real name. The court found that the plaintiff’s concerns about embarrassment or disclosure of medical information did not outweigh the public’s interest in open judicial proceedings, particularly in a class action context.

JANE DOE, individually & on behalf of all others similarly situated, Plaintiff, v. CALL-ON DOC, INC., Defendant., No. 24CV2095-GPC(KSC), 2025 WL 1677632 (S.D. Cal. June 13, 2025).

Tags

art iii injury-in-fact, cipa section 631, cmia, personal jurisdiction
chevron-up