A U.S. District Court for the Central District of California granted defendants’ motion to compel arbitration despite their failure to pay arbitration fees.
The case involves a putative class action brought by a user of the Pornhub website, alleging wrongful disclosure of personal data to a third party (Google) in violation of the Video Privacy Protection Act. The defendants, a group of related companies operating the website, sought to compel arbitration based on the site’s terms of service.
Plaintiff initiated arbitration with the American Arbitration Association (AAA) as required by the site’s terms of service. Defendants failed to timely pay the required arbitration fees as required under California Code of Civil Procedure section 1281.97. As a result, AAA closed the case. Plaintiff then filed suit in federal court, arguing that the defendants waived their right to arbitrate by missing the payment deadline.
Defendants countered that the California statute was preempted by the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA) and that any issues regarding waiver or breach should be decided by the arbitrator, not the court.
The court focused on whether it or the arbitrator should decide if the defendants’ failure to pay fees constituted a waiver of the right to arbitrate. The court found that the arbitration agreement incorporated the AAA rules, which delegate questions of arbitrability—including waiver, breach, and preemption—to the arbitrator. The court cited Ninth Circuit precedent holding that such incorporation is “clear and unmistakable evidence” of the parties’ intent to delegate these gateway issues.
The court also rejected the plaintiff’s argument that the defendants’ failure to pay fees invalidated the delegation clause itself, finding that the challenge was to the arbitration agreement as a whole, not specifically to the delegation provision.
“[A]rbitration is fundamentally a matter of contract ….” Momot v. Mastro, 652 F.3d 982, 986 (9th Cir. 2011). Accordingly, while “gateway issues of arbitrability presumptively are reserved for the court, … parties may agree to delegate them to the arbitrator,” id., so long as “there is clear and unmistakableevidence that they did so,” First Options of Chicago, Inc. v. Kaplan, 514 U.S. 938, 944 (1995) (cleaned up).
Defendants argue that the parties incorporated the AAA rules into the arbitration agreement, which constitutes clear and unmistakable intent to delegate gateway issues to the arbitrator. (Mot. 10.) Plaintiff does not address whether the agreement incorporates the AAA rules. Based on the Court’s review of the terms of service, the Court finds that it does. (See Lisy Decl. Ex. A, at 24, ECF No. 31-3 (“All controversies, claims, counterclaims, or other disputes arising between you and us or you and a third-party agent of ours (each a ‘Claim’) shall be submitted for binding arbitration in accordance with the Rules of the American Arbitration Association (‘AAA Rules’).”).) The Ninth Circuit has held that incorporating the rules of an arbitral body like the AAA that provide for delegation “constitutes clear and unmistakableevidence that contracting parties agreed to arbitrate arbitrability.” Brennan, 796 F.3d at 1130. Because the Court finds that this constitutes clear and unmistakableevidence, the Court does not address the parties’ arguments as to whether the express language in the terms of service providing for delegation demonstrates the same. (See Lisy Decl. Ex. A, at 24.)
*3 The parties do not address whether the issue of section 1281.97’s preemption is similarly delegated to the arbitrator. However, in an unpublished decision, a Ninth Circuit panel determined a party’s argument for withdrawal from arbitration based on the other’s violation of section 1281.97 fell “squarely within the scope of the delegation clause, and … should have been left to the arbitrator to decide.” See Dekker v. Vivint Solar, Inc., No. 20-16584, 2021 WL 4958856, at *1 (9th Cir. Oct. 26, 2021). In the Court’s view, this reasoning extends to the situation here, where one party argues for a section 1281.97 waiver and the other responds that federal law preempts the argument.
Jane Doe et al. v. Aylo Holdings S.a.r.l., et al. Additional Party Names: 9219-1568 Quebec Inc., Aylo Billing Ltd., Aylo Billing US Corp., Aylo CY Holdings LTD, Aylo Freesites Ltd, Aylo Glob. Ent. Inc., Aylo Grp. Ltd, Aylo USA Inc., Toqon, LLC, No. 2:24-CV-03267-MCS-JPR, 2025 WL 1461138 (C.D. Cal. Feb. 24, 2025).
