This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.
| 1 minute read

Pornhub Tracking Claims Survive Against Site Operators Based on Alleged Collection of Sensitive Viewing Data

Judge Wesley L. Hsu, of the Central District of California, dismissed several defendants from a putative class action. Those defendants did not direct activities to California, and the plaintiffs' claims are unrelated to the business of those defendants.

Background: Plaintiffs alleged that Pornhub embedded third-party trackers that collected and transmitted information concerning users’ pornography viewing habits, search terms, sexual-orientation categories, product purchases, and related browsing activity. Plaintiffs asserted CIPA, invasion-of-privacy, and intrusion-upon-seclusion claims, alleging that the trackers transmitted sensitive user information to analytics and advertising providers in real time without Plaintiffs’ knowledge or consent.

Analysis: The court dismissed several Aylo entities for lack of personal jurisdiction after concluding plaintiffs failed to connect the alleged website-tracking activity to those entities’ California contacts.

Plaintiffs do not factually support their allegation that Defendants Aylo Holdings, Aylo Global, and AyloUSA targeted advertisements to consumers in California.

Defendants Aylo Holdings, Aylo Global, and AyloUSA, however, assert through sworn testimony that they do not operate or market Pornhub and that they are engaged in other business lines unrelated to the website.

...

Even assuming, arguendo, Plaintiffs had plausibly alleged that Defendants Aylo Holdings, Aylo Global and Aylo USA's actual activities occurred in or are directed at California (they do not), Plaintiffs' claims do not arise out of those activities and thus fail to establish the second prong of the Ninth Circuit's test.

The court nevertheless held that plaintiffs plausibly alleged a CIPA claim against the remaining defendants because the complaint described specific tracking technologies, without consent, that allegedly intercepted and transmitted user interactions in real time while communications were in transit. The court rejected defendants’ argument that the interception allegations were merely conclusory, emphasizing the detailed allegations regarding how the trackers functioned and what categories of information they collected. The court also held that plaintiffs plausibly alleged invasion-of-privacy and intrusion-upon-seclusion claims because the alleged tracking involved highly sensitive data concerning pornography consumption and sexual interests.

Significance: The decision reflects courts’ increasing willingness to view pornography-viewing information as among the most sensitive categories of internet activity. It also reinforces that detailed allegations regarding how specific tracking technologies operate may be sufficient to satisfy CIPA’s “in transit” requirement at the pleading stage.

Adair v. Aylo USA Inc., No. 2:25-CV

chevron-up