This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.
| 2 minute read

Student Data Privacy Claims Against EdTech Provider Dismissed Across All Theories for Pleading Deficiencies

Addressing the elements of each claim, Judge Fred W. Slaughter, of the Central District of California, granted defendant's motion to dismiss, in its entirety, with leave to amend.

Background. Minor students, through their guardians, sued Renaissance Learning over educational software used in K–12 schools. The complaint alleged that Renaissance collected and shared students’ identifying, educational, and behavioral data for commercial purposes without informed consent. The plaintiffs asserted federal and state wiretapping and privacy claims, CIPA’s pen-register provision, CDAFA, UCL, negligence, the Washington Data Transparency and Privacy Act, unjust enrichment, and related theories based on alleged COPPA and FERPA representations. Renaissance moved to dismiss.

The Court’s Analysis. The court dismissed all claims with leave to amend because the complaint failed to tie Renaissance's alleged data-collection practices to a legally cognizable injury. Although the complaint described the types of information the platform could collect and share, it did not plausibly allege an actionable privacy invasion, unlawful interception, or other concrete harm. The court rejected the wiretap theories because Renaissance participated in the communications at issue and found no basis to apply the crime-tort exception. It likewise found the remaining statutory and common-law claims deficient for lack of facts showing the type of injury, damages, or wrongful conduct required to state a claim.

Plaintiffs allege they have lost “money or property, as a result of Renaissance's unfair and unlawful practices, which include the unauthorized disclosure and taking of their personal information that has value as demonstrated by its use and sale by Renaissance,” and “have suffered harm in the form of diminution of the value of their private and personally identifiable data and content.” (FAC ¶ 428; see also id. ¶¶ 330-31 & 55 (“Renaissance has diminished the value of Plaintiffs' personal information, without compensation or other legally sufficient consideration,” “deprived students of their choice of whether to participate in the data market at all,” and that “Renaissance's nonconsensual data practices have prevented the development of a legitimate market for student data.”).)

The court is not persuaded that the FAC alleges a loss of money or property sufficient to support UCL standing. In particular, Plaintiffs' theory requires making multiple logical leaps—including that a market for student data collected pursuant to corporate contracts with schools would exist and that Plaintiffs could and would have participated in such a market if it existed—each of which is rife with speculation and not an adequate foundation for the “los[s of] money or property as a result of [Renaissance's alleged] unfair competition” that is required to bring a UCL claim.

Applying ordinary plausibility standards, the court required allegations of actual harm stemming from the challenged practices rather than broad assertions about the platform's data-collection capabilities.

Significance. Educational technology providers face heightened scrutiny because the data may relate to minors, but sensitivity alone does not cure pleading defects. Complaints must identify the actual collection and disclosure pathway, overcome the party exemption where applicable, and plead concrete damages or a legally recognized privacy injury.

Reisberg v. Renaissance Learning, Inc., No. 8:25-CV-01379-FWS-JDE, 2026 WL 1048242 (C.D. Cal. Feb. 17, 2026).

chevron-up