Judge Gonzalo P. Curiel, in the Southern District of California, granted in part and denied in part, defendant's motion to dismiss or strike. Plaintiffs were given leave to amend.
Background. The plaintiffs alleged that Endurance sent unsolicited vehicle-warranty emails using third-party domain names, falsified header information, and misleading subject lines. Plaintiffs alleged that they received multiple similar emails without consenting to commercial messages and that, after clicking through, the advertised price reduction could not be found on Endurance’s website. Their complaint asserted separate theories under California Business and Professions Code Section 17529.5(a)(1), (a)(2), and (a)(3). Endurance moved to dismiss or strike the complaint.
The Court’s Analysis. The court applied CAN-SPAM’s preemption framework, which preserves state laws directed to falsity or deception but displaces state rules imposing only technical requirements on email domains or headers. It therefore dismissed the Section 17529.5(a)(1) and (a)(2) claims as preempted: the alleged use of unauthorized domains and inaccurate header information did not, without more, amount to material deception. The Section 17529.5(a)(3) subject-line claim survived because the complaint alleged that reasonable recipients could be misled about the content or material facts of the offer, including the price reduction that was unavailable after clicking through.
Significance. State email claims are more likely to survive CAN-SPAM preemption when they allege material deception rather than technical header or domain defects. Marketing programs should distinguish true sender-identification compliance from the separate obligation to ensure that subject lines accurately describe the offer.
Rodriguez v. Endurance Warranty Servs., L.L.C., No. 3:25-CV-02694-GPC-KSC, 2026 WL 1110696 (S.D. Cal. Apr. 23, 2026).
