This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.
| 1 minute read

California Superior Court Allows Website Tracking Claim Under Trap-and-Trace Statute to Proceed

Judge Richard S. Kemalyan, of the Los Angeles County Superior Court, overruled defendant's demurrer, finding that the statute was capable to covering the alleged technology.

Background: Plaintiff alleged that S&B Filters used website tracking technology that captured identifying information from visitors to its website without obtaining the court order required by California’s trap-and-trace statute, Penal Code section 638.51. The complaint sought relief under the statutory private right of action and alleged that defendant’s tracking technology operated as a prohibited trap-and-trace device or process.

Analysis: The court overruled the demurrer and allowed the claim to proceed. It rejected defendant’s argument that website tracking software cannot qualify as a trap-and-trace device, noting that defendant relied primarily on an unpublished superior court decision while numerous federal courts have concluded that software-based tracking technologies may fall within the statute’s scope. The court further declined to find, at the pleading stage, that a retailer operating a commercial website qualifies as a provider of electronic communication services exempt from liability. The complaint also alleged collection of more than just IP addresses, including other forms of routing and identifying information. Finally, the court rejected defendant’s contention that the claim required proof of a reasonable expectation of privacy, observing that the statute focuses on the alleged use of a prohibited device or process rather than traditional privacy-based elements.

The court separately struck plaintiff’s request for punitive damages, concluding that the complaint alleged only a statutory cause of action with its own detailed remedial scheme, including statutory penalties, treble damages, and injunctive relief. The court allowed the request for attorneys' fees to remain, noting that fees under Code of Civil Procedure section 1021.5 are ordinarily addressed through a post-judgment motion rather than the pleadings.

Esparza v. S&B Filters, Inc., No. 25STCV15352, 2026 WL 1424647 (Cal.Super. Mar. 03, 2026).

chevron-up