This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.
| 1 minute read

Arbitration Compelled Against Both Signatory and Nonsignatory Platform Partner via Equitable Estoppel

Judge Daniel J. Calabretta, of the Eastern District of California, granted defendants' motion to compel arbitration as to both the signatory and nonsignatory.

Background. Johnson brought a putative class action against Overstock.com, Beyond, and Shopify alleging that website trackers violated CIPA, CDAFA, and the California constitutional right to privacy. She alleged that Shopify and Overstock used cookies and tracking technologies to collect and share information such as IP address, operating system, geolocation, purchase details, payment-related information, and other data used for risk scoring and cross-site tracking. Johnson enrolled in Overstock email communications, and the enrollment process presented Terms and Conditions containing an arbitration clause and delegation clause, along with a Privacy Policy describing third-party cookies and sharing. Overstock and Shopify moved to compel arbitration after removal from state court.

The Court’s Analysis. The court held that Johnson consented to Overstock’s arbitration agreement when she enrolled in email communications and failed to exercise the stated opt-out right. The agreement contained a clear delegation clause assigning the arbitrator authority over scope, validity, and enforceability, and Johnson did not meaningfully challenge that provision. Shopify was not a signatory, but the court applied California’s equitable-estoppel doctrine because Johnson’s claims against Shopify were intimately founded in and intertwined with Overstock’s Terms and Privacy Policy. The Privacy Policy addressed Overstock’s practice of tracking pixels, cookies, and collection by third-party providers. Because resolving the claims would require deciding the scope of those contractual disclosures, Shopify could enforce the arbitration clause as a nonsignatory. The case was stayed pending arbitration.

Johnson v. Beyond, Inc., No. 2:25-CV-03327-DJC-CSK, 2026 WL 1076039 (E.D. Cal. Apr. 21, 2026).

chevron-up