Judge Dale S. Fisher, of the Central District of California, granted defendant's motion to compel arbitration under the Federal Arbitration Act.
Background. Plaintiffs brought a California privacy class action alleging that Walmart disclosed personal and health information to Facebook through its website. They purchased products through Walmart.com after completing a checkout process in which the “Place Order” button sat immediately next to or above language stating that placing the order meant agreeing to Walmart’s hyperlinked Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. The Terms prominently warned of mandatory individual arbitration, a class-action waiver, and delegation of arbitrability questions under AAA rules. Walmart removed the case and moved to compel arbitration and stay the action.
The Court’s Analysis. Applying the FAA and Ninth Circuit online-contract principles, the court characterized Walmart’s mechanism as a sign-in wrap rather than browsewrap. The hyperlink was adjacent to the operative button, the Terms link was visibly underlined, and the Terms placed the arbitration and class waiver in capitalized language at the top. The checkout language expressly told users that clicking the button constituted agreement, so the plaintiffs manifested assent without having to open the Terms. The court separately enforced the delegation clause because incorporation of AAA rules clearly assigned gateway questions to the arbitrator. Challenges based on adhesion, unilateral modification, and unconscionability did not overcome the clear notice and the absence of meaningful oppression or surprise.
Significance. The decision confirms that arbitration provisions in online retail terms are more defensible when the assent language is adjacent to the transaction button and the arbitration waiver is prominently disclosed in the linked terms. To survive unconscionability challenges, delegation provisions should be equally clear if the business wants arbitrability issues decided by the arbitrator.
Bonkowski v. Walmart Inc., No. 2:25-CV-01462-DSF-PVC, 2025 WL 4688082 (C.D. Cal. June 17, 2025).
