Judge John F. Walter, of the Central District of California, granted defendant's motion to dismiss a putative class action alleging website tracking claims. The court found that plaintiff consent to tracking when he accepted the website terms of service and acknowledged the privacy policy in the appointment scheduling process.
Background. Sisti, a Maryland resident, alleged that Bosley’s medical hair-loss consultation website disclosed information to Meta and TikTok through tracking pixels. The complaint claims under the ECPA, California Confidentiality of Medical Information Act, CIPA, Maryland Wiretap Act, Maryland Consumer Protection Act, negligence, unjust enrichment, and intrusion upon seclusion. Sisti characterized the fact that he scheduled a consultation, together with identifiers sent through the pixels, as health-related information and alleged that Bosley used the information for targeted advertising. After the case was transferred to the Central District of California, Bosley moved to dismiss the amended complaint.
The Court’s Analysis. The court held that Popa v. Microsoft requires a concrete injury beyond a statutory violation. Sisti did not allege that Bosley transmitted actual health information, that he became a patient, attended a clinic visit, or paid for medical services. The court therefore could not determine what sensitive information had been disclosed or how the disclosure intruded on his private affairs. It also found consent because the scheduling page conspicuously stated that submitting the form constituted agreement to the Terms of Service and acknowledgment of the Privacy Policy—a sign-in-wrap agreement that required an affirmative act. The policies disclosed third-party cookies, user identification, and advertising uses. Those findings defeated the ECPA, CIPA, CMIA, and Maryland claims, while the remaining tort, consumer-protection, and unjust-enrichment theories lacked injury or a plausible unlawful purpose. Dismissal was with prejudice because amendment would be futile.
Significance. The ruling shows that a medical or health-oriented website does not automatically make every interaction health data for Article III purposes. Clear notice tied to an affirmative submission action can also support consent across multiple privacy statutes when the challenged disclosure matches the disclosures in the site terms.
Sisti v. Bosley Inc., 831 F. Supp. 3d 979 (C.D. Cal. 2026).
