Jude Josephine L. Staton, of the Central District of California, granted a motion dismiss website tracking claims based on a lack of injury.
Background. Garcia visited giftcards.com and selected the site’s “Required only” cookie setting, alleging that Blackhawk nevertheless caused third-party cookies to be placed on her browser. Her complaint alleged the collection of browsing and visit history, website interactions, user inputs, demographic data, shopping behavior, device information, identifiers, and geolocation. It identified entities across the digital advertising ecosystem could use the information to create profiles and facilitate targeted marketing efforts. Garcia asserted ECPA, CIPA (Sections 638.51 and 631(a)), invasion of privacy, fraud, and unjust-enrichment claims. After removal, Blackhawk moved to dismiss for lack of Article III standing.
The Court’s Analysis. Applying Popa v. Microsoft, the court asked whether the alleged tracking was highly offensive because it involved especially sensitive information or unusually broad monitoring. Activity confined to a single gift-card website was comparable to ordinary commercial observation, and the complaint identified no embarrassing or invasive private information. The court also found that Garcia pleaded only generalized capabilities of tracking software rather than facts showing which cookies were installed on her device, what they collected from her, or how Blackhawk caused any cross-site profiling allegedly performed by other entities. With no concrete injury supporting the ECPA claim, the court dismissed that federal claim and declined supplemental jurisdiction over the state claims, granting leave to amend or remand.
Garcia v. Blackhawk Network, Inc., No. 2:25-CV-07550-JLS-SSC, 2026 WL 925028 (C.D. Cal. Apr. 1, 2026).
