This browser is not actively supported anymore. For the best passle experience, we strongly recommend you upgrade your browser.
| 1 minute read

Collection of IP Addresses and Device Data Insufficient to Establish Article III Standing

Judge Maxine Chesney, of the Northern District of California, granted defendant's motion to dismiss the consolidated class action complaint based on lack of Art. III standing.

Background. The consolidated plaintiffs alleged that USA Today embedded third-party trackers on its website and collected IP addresses, device type, browser type, location, time, connection type, browsing behavior, and other information used for audience targeting. They asserted claims under CDAFA, CIPA Section 638.51, the California Constitution, the UCL, and unjust enrichment, and alleged both privacy and economic injuries. USA Today moved to dismiss the First Consolidated Class Action Complaint. The Northern District of California addressed standing before reaching the statutory merits.

The Court’s Analysis. Relying on Popa v. Microsoft and TransUnion, the court held that plaintiffs had to identify a concrete injury with a close historical or common-law analogue; alleging a statutory violation was not enough. IP addresses and ordinary device information were not treated as legally protected privacy interests, and the complaint did not identify unique, persistent identifiers or sensitive content with enough specificity. The claimed economic injury also failed because the plaintiffs did not adequately allege that USA Today collected information in which they had a protectable privacy interest or that any resulting profit was unjust.

Plaintiffs next contend they allege “economic harm sufficient for Article III standing,” namely, the financial value of “user data” (see id. ¶ 34) by which USA Today allegedly has been “unjustly enrich[ed]” (see id. ¶ 170). “California law recognizes a legal interest in unjustly earned profits.” See In re Facebook, Inc. Internet Tracking Litig., 956 F.3d 589, 600 (9th Cir. 2020). As discussed above, however, plaintiffs fail to adequately allege collection by USA Today of information in which plaintiffs had a legally protected privacy interest and, consequently, fail to allege any profit earned therefrom was unjust.

The court dismissed the complaint for lack of subject matter jurisdiction but allowed amendment, warning that the case would otherwise be remanded.

In re USA Today Co., Inc. Internet Tracking Litig., No. 24-CV-05150-MMC, 2026 WL 932655 (N.D. Cal. Apr. 6, 2026).

chevron-up